I thought I had already posted this last week, but apparently not. I tweeted at the time, “I read this as Bonnie Stewart running smack-dab into ‘groups versus networks’ and opting for groups.” Stewart summarizes, “digital identity, as a practice, operates counter to the collaboration and cooperation that need to be part of digital citizenship.” Read the excellent 75 page slide deck pursuing that idea. There’s a line of argumentation there to the effect that there is a duty of care that is not recognized by digital identity. Or to employ Chris Lott’s “Explain it Like I am Five” version, “we don’ t make a better society just by making ourselves better.” I think this is an impoverished account of identity, digital or otherwise. The only way to make ourselves better is to make society better. It’s not an ethical thing. It’s not a citizenship thing. It’s a practical thing.
Source: New feed2